Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bryan Winchell's avatar

Well, FWIW, I may not be your younger self, Adam (in fact, I’m older than you if we’re simply using number of solar returns to count), but your articles, and your podcasts, always speak to me, and I’m always grateful when your voice catches my attention (as it just did now by way of a Substack notification, one of the only apps I allow notifications for, appearing at the top of my phone just as I was wrapping up my pre-sleep round of Duo Lingo language learning).

Anyway, I share your concerns about the poor quality of LLM’s for being a true sub for us human astrologers. I feel like the few times I’ve asked one an astrological question, it gets the first answer wrong in some very obvious way and I then spend my time correcting the darn thing.

For example, just this weekend, I asked for a list of Jupiter-in-Gemini transits using tropical astrology dating from 1960 to 2030 and, after it made a preliminary comment about how Jupiter takes about 12 years to go through the Zodiac, it listed the current transit and the previous one correctly, before listing the one before that as sometime in 2008! When I pointed out that 2008 was not, by any standard form of counting 12 years before the 2012-13 transit, it apologized and said that the only sources it had used which were reliable were for the current and 2012-13 one!

Perhaps the bright side is we’ll be able which astrological content creators are merely spitting out what these apps are feeding them and we can then, in honor the Virgo archetype, easily separate the wheat from the chaff.

Anyway, for the time being at least, I’m reasonably sure you are still a proper human with astrological accuracy, depth and wisdom!

Expand full comment
Camille Sheppard's avatar

Did you write this for me? 😂 I actually did a reading last month without any research or outside sources. I had to becuase I had the wrong birth date (10-9 is 9-10 some places in the world and you'd think that would be obvious to me but it slipped my mind). Truth be told, it was the best error I've ever made because I discovered that I could do it. She loved the reading and my confidence in my reading skills took a big jump.

With my moon, IC and sun all in Jupiter's steamroller path through Gemini, my challenge this year is to go with less to combat Jupiter's more. I can feel how important this will be already. It's not like I don't do the meditation, the sitting with my own thoughts, reading real books etc... I just do too much of all of it and am always feeling like I should "read one more article" etc. This will be my year of practicing a new approach. One less...

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts